28. Baby Snatcher and Zaddy Joe Kenda
Join us this week as cover another cuckoo bananas person doing a crazy thing. This week, Erin watched Baby Snatcher, …
27. Fatal Honeymoon and Coffee & Conspiracies
Visit the subreddit Paul mentioned here. Join us this week as we cover the world’s biggest douchebag! Erin watched Fatal …
26. Obsessed and Sexy SAT Words
Join us this week as we cover one crazy wackadoodle! Erin tells us about the movie Obsessed, how to tell if …
25. Abducted: The Jocelyn Shaker Story and Karma’s Abs
Join us this week as we cover a movie and case that are…kind of connected if you squint and turn …
24. The Murder of Princess Diana and Add More Charleses
This week we switch things up a bit! Paul watched “The Murder of Princess Diana” in which Jennifer Morrison plays …
23. A Girl Like Me and You Can’t See Our Middle Fingers
This week is a tough one. Erin watched A Girl Like Me: The Gwen Araujo Story. We shame IMDb a …
22. Casualties of Love and Really Boring Porn
This week, Erin watched Casualties of Love: The Long Island Lolita Story and Paul researched the true case of Amy …
21. Terror in the Woods and Slenderman-by-Proxy
Paul’s Sources: Slender Man on Wikipedia Slender Man Stabbing on Wikipedia Courthouse News Service WISN News – Waukesha This week …
20. Murder in Mexico and Pimp My David
Sources: Bruce Beresford-Redman on Wikipedia The Hollywood Reporter ABC News Join us this week for the most boring movie and …
19. Girl Fight and the Little Pinger
Paul’s Sources: The Mulberry Eight – Encyclopedia Dramatica In the Spotlite Blog The Trench Reynolds Report New York Times The …
18. Oscar Pistorius and Douchebaggius Assholiosis
Oscar Pistorius on Wikipedia Real Crime Profile Episode 21: The Murder of Reeva Steenkamp by Oscar Pistorius Internet Sleuths Podcast …
17. Big Little Lies and This Isn’t Lifetime Anymore
Toto, we’re not watching the Lifetime Channel anymore! Join Paul and Erin for their official Patreon preview where they discuss …
16. The Craigslist Killer and the Blatant Erection
Paul’s Sources: Biography of Philip Markoff from Biography.com Philip Markoff from Wikipedia The Craigslist Killer from Crime Museum The Craigslist …
15. The Girl in the Bathtub
Paul’s Sources: Is ‘The Girl In The Bathtub’ Based On A True Story? The Lifetime Drama Is Ripped From The …
14. Manson’s Lost Girls and the Never Ending Orgy
Sources and Links: Linda Kasabian Biography from Biography.com Linda Kasabian Was Charles Manson’s Lover Until She Brought The Whole Manson …
13. Perfect Sisters and the Secret Glee Club Meeting
Erin’s Selected Links: Tales of Erotica Movie Trailer Vanity Fair Article about Fan Bingbing Paul’s Sources: Wikipedia – The Murder …
12. We Have Your Husband and the Law According to Erin
Join Paul and Erin this week as they laugh, cry, and beg a Federali to take his shirt off. Erin …
11. I Killed My BFF and Mansplaining 101
This week, Erin watched I Killed My BFF, a crazy movie with an unpredictable ending, despite the title. Listen to …
10. An Officer and a Murderer and the Scrapbook of Shame
Join us as Erin tells Paul about An Officer and a Murderer and Russell Williams. We chat about his disturbing …
9. Hannah Anderson and the Tree Shoots Back
This week, Erin watched either Kidnapped: Hannah Anderson or Kidnapped: The Hannah Anderson Story, depending on which source you look …
