82. Sleeping with Danger and He Should Not Be A Doctor

81. Fab Five: The Texas Cheerleader Scandal and the Soapbox Special

80. The Texas Cadet Murders and Shakespearean Carnal Knowledge

79. Held Hostage and The Missing Roommate

78. Two More Stories From Our Patreon Vault

77. Trapped: The Alex Cooper Story and Mushing Mouth Parts

76. Daughter For Sale and Twerking to Beethoven’s Ninth

75. Betty & Coretta and Even the Amish Know!

74. I Was Lorena Bobbitt and Spoiler Alert: It’s a Penis

73. Death of a Cheerleader and Quidditch Night at the Weasleys’ House

72. Who Is Clark Rockefeller? and Andy Bernard Saves the Day

71. Patreon Vault – The Gardner Museum Heist and Amelia Earhart

70. Britney Ever After and This is a Stick In

69. Girl in the Box and I Kissed Hitchhiking Goodbye

68. I Killed My BFF: The Preacher’s Daughter and Children, Know Your Worth

67. Cleveland Abductions and An HGTV Torture Chamber

This week we cover another super dark case so buckle up! Erin watched Cleveland Abduction which, when combined with Serial …

49. Midwest Obsession and the Cow Print Convertible

This week’s episode is brought to you by…COWS! Erin watched Midwest Obsession, or Beauty’s Revenge (depending on who you ask) …

47. Robert Durst and The Inspiration for Dear Prudence

This week we talk about Erin’s favorite case! It’s got drag! It’s got people stealing from the grocery store while …

46. Taken in Broad Daylight and You Don’t Have to Take My Word For It

This week’s movie was a bust. You’d think with James Van Der Beek, and Levar Burton Lifetime could have done …