67. Cleveland Abductions and An HGTV Torture Chamber
This week we cover another super dark case so buckle up! Erin watched Cleveland Abduction which, when combined with Serial …
49. Midwest Obsession and the Cow Print Convertible
This week’s episode is brought to you by…COWS! Erin watched Midwest Obsession, or Beauty’s Revenge (depending on who you ask) …
48. New York Prison Break and That’s Not How You Wave
Another week, another hot mess! This week, Erin watched New York Prison Break: The Seduction of Joyce Mitchell, starring pod …
47. Robert Durst and The Inspiration for Dear Prudence
This week we talk about Erin’s favorite case! It’s got drag! It’s got people stealing from the grocery store while …
46. Taken in Broad Daylight and You Don’t Have to Take My Word For It
This week’s movie was a bust. You’d think with James Van Der Beek, and Levar Burton Lifetime could have done …
45. Beautiful & Twisted and A Lot of Million Dollars
Buckle up because it’s going to be a wild ride! This week Erin watched THE BEST MOVIE EVER, Beautiful & …
44. No One Would Tell and Freaky Time Tips
IT’S CCB WEEK Y’ALL!! This week Erin watched “No One Would Tell” a movie in which a high school aged …
43. Murder in the Hamptons and The Girl Child, Schmaschmexa
TW: Turn off your Alexa for this one!! This week we celebrate the beginning of It’s A Wonderful Lifetime and …
41. College Admissions Scandal and Aunt Becky’s AK-47
This week, it’s finally here! The story of how Aunt Becky fell from grace! This week, we watched the creatively …
42. Scared Silent and We All Hate Flowered Shorts
This week, Erin watched Scared Silent, a movie that has all of her least favorite plot points. Terrible police work …
41. College Admissions Scandal and Aunt Becky’s AK-47
This week, it’s finally here! The story of how Aunt Becky fell from grace! This week, we watched the creatively …
40. Abducted: Mary Stauffer and Dammit, Irv!
This week, we begrudgingly talk about The Mary Stauffer Story. Erin and Paul discuss the finer points of the phrase …
39. Believe Me and Dear 80s, Invent the Internet
This week Erin wants to burn it all down. She watched Believe Me: The Abduction of Lisa McVey. (TW: the …
