40. Abducted: Mary Stauffer and Dammit, Irv!
This week, we begrudgingly talk about The Mary Stauffer Story. Erin and Paul discuss the finer points of the phrase …
39. Believe Me and Dear 80s, Invent the Internet
This week Erin wants to burn it all down. She watched Believe Me: The Abduction of Lisa McVey. (TW: the …
38. Escaping the NXIVM Cult and Rage Ending a Cult
This week we learn all about female empowerment from the one person that will always know female empowerment best…a man. …
37. Girl Scout Camp Murders
This week, Erin and Paul took a break from recording so they could go finally be in the same room …
36. A Sister’s Secret and Erin is the Real Victim Here
This week we drive Erin to the brink of insanity with the most unbelievable and disturbing plot yet. A Sister’s …
35. Cry in the Wild and The Dynamic Duo: Two Belts and Zero Tact
This week we throw back to the 60’s when people still had outhouses, and police had ZERO idea what they …
34. Lies My Mother Told Me and The Jeebus Fantasy Court TV League
This week we cover a crazy lady with LOTS of names. Erin watched ‘Lies My Mother Told Me’. We talk …
33: A Date With Darkness and the Accepted Definition of Skinny Dipping
Grab a cocktail because you’re going to need it. Erin watched “Date With Darkness” a movie about Max Factor’s great …
32. The Watcher and Birds, Bed, Bath, and Beyond
This week, nobody died for real, but several people die in the worst movie ever. Erin watched The Watcher and …
31. Secrets of My Stepdaughter and Gluten-Free Shoes
This week it’s the perfect family and leggings for everyone! Erin watched “Secrets of my Stepdaughter” a movie where the …
30. Night Stalker and Now Streaming on Ouija Boards
This week it’s out with the stalkers and in with the creepy serial killers. Erin watched The Night Stalker and …
29. Intimate Stranger and Comic Sans Chloroform
This week we have another stalker for you! Erin watched Intimate Stranger, a movie about a guy with too much …
28. Baby Snatcher and Zaddy Joe Kenda
Join us this week as cover another cuckoo bananas person doing a crazy thing. This week, Erin watched Baby Snatcher, …
27. Fatal Honeymoon and Coffee & Conspiracies
Visit the subreddit Paul mentioned here. Join us this week as we cover the world’s biggest douchebag! Erin watched Fatal …
26. Obsessed and Sexy SAT Words
Join us this week as we cover one crazy wackadoodle! Erin tells us about the movie Obsessed, how to tell if …
25. Abducted: The Jocelyn Shaker Story and Karma’s Abs
Join us this week as we cover a movie and case that are…kind of connected if you squint and turn …
24. The Murder of Princess Diana and Add More Charleses
This week we switch things up a bit! Paul watched “The Murder of Princess Diana” in which Jennifer Morrison plays …
23. A Girl Like Me and You Can’t See Our Middle Fingers
This week is a tough one. Erin watched A Girl Like Me: The Gwen Araujo Story. We shame IMDb a …
22. Casualties of Love and Really Boring Porn
This week, Erin watched Casualties of Love: The Long Island Lolita Story and Paul researched the true case of Amy …
21. Terror in the Woods and Slenderman-by-Proxy
Paul’s Sources: Slender Man on Wikipedia Slender Man Stabbing on Wikipedia Courthouse News Service WISN News – Waukesha This week …
